The LDS Church called the priesthood ban a "direct commandment from the Lord" for 126 years. In 2013, they published an essay. We read both — and the gap between them is the whole story.
Jess and Hannah read the primary sources the 2013 Gospel Topics Essay on Race and the Priesthood was written to address — and then read the essay itself. Brigham Young's 1852 speeches. The 1949 First Presidency statement that called the ban "founding doctrine" and declared there was "no injustice whatsoever." Mark E. Peterson's 1954 BYU address laying out the pre-mortal valiance framework. Bruce R. McConkie's Mormon Doctrine, published by Deseret Book and cited in Sunday schools for decades. Then: what the essay says, what word it uses to describe all of the above, and what the 1949 statement's complete absence from the published text tells you about the choices an institution makes when it's trying to close a record without opening accountability. Disavowal is real. It isn't the same as an apology. The church hasn't issued one, and Dallin H. Oaks has explained — in his own words — exactly why it won't.
Support the show: buymeacoffee.com/postmormonpostmortem
Ad-free listening from $2/month: patreon.com/postmormonpostmortem
TikTok & Instagram: @postmormonpostmortem postmormonpostmortem.com
New episodes every Sunday at 9 AM — just in time for sacrament meeting.
01:45 Historical Context of Racial Teachings in the Church
02:41 Brigham Young's Controversial Statements
05:03 The Role of Black Figures in Early Church History
06:31 The Evolution of Church Doctrine on Race
07:59 The Impact of Church Teachings on Racial Perceptions
09:52 The 1978 Revelation and Its Implications
12:06 Reflections on Personal Experiences with Church Teachings
14:11 Conclusion and Call to Action
21:06 The Legacy of Exclusion
22:50 Institutional Necessity and Revelation
25:03 The 2013 Essay: A Quiet Reckoning
27:14 Theories and Doctrines: A Historical Perspective
30:27 The Role of Leadership in Doctrine
33:25 The Church's Response to Racial History
36:26 The Complexity of Accountability
41:50 The Absence of Apology
45:20 The Impact of the Ban on Families
48:54 Disavowal vs. Accountability
49:45 Patterns of Institutional Response
01:45 Historical Context of Racial Teachings in the Church
02:41 Brigham Young's Controversial Statements
05:03 The Role of Black Figures in Early Church History
06:31 The Evolution of Church Doctrine on Race
07:59 The Impact of Church Teachings on Racial Perceptions
09:52 The 1978 Revelation and Its Implications
12:06 Reflections on Personal Experiences with Church Teachings
14:11 Conclusion and Call to Action
21:06 The Legacy of Exclusion
22:50 Institutional Necessity and Revelation
25:03 The 2013 Essay: A Quiet Reckoning
27:14 Theories and Doctrines: A Historical Perspective
30:27 The Role of Leadership in Doctrine
33:25 The Church's Response to Racial History
36:26 The Complexity of Accountability
41:50 The Absence of Apology
45:20 The Impact of the Ban on Families
48:54 Disavowal vs. Accountability
49:45 Patterns of Institutional Response